You Tried Dat??

It's a fudge covered sandwich cookie showdown!  The recently re-released fudge covered Oreos square off against the brand new fudge covered Nutter Butters.  Will the peanut butter goodness of the Nutter Butter be enough to stave off the juggernaut that is Oreo?  Only the You Tried Dat?? crew has the both the intestinal fortitude and the intestinal lining to make the call.