Starkey & Mueller

Hour 2: Is it true that Aaron Rodgers was actually the Steelers' Plan C? Dom says that Bob Pompeani has hit rock bottom. And Jeff Hathhorn joins the show for an Oakmont Minute.

Dan Zangrilli jumps on with Poni to talk about whether or not Paul Skenes could win the Cy Young Award this year, if Don Kelly will be back in 2026, if he's ever done hard drugs, and more!

Hour 1: Poni has had an Aaron Rodgers epiphany. Just how good were Rodgers' last few seasons? And Dan Zangrilli joins the show to talk Paul Skenes, Don Kelly, and more!

Aaron Rodgers will be a Steelers. We have instant reaction from our hosts, our callers and where the team can go from here.

PM Team FULL Show 6-6-25

What is the ceiling for the Steelers with Aaron Rodgers? What is the worst-case scenario for the Steelers? The guys still pondered if it would be better for their future if they just had one lackluster season. Former Steeler Bryant McFadden joined the show. Bryant thinks Aaron Rodgers is still a 6 or 7 out of 10 even at 41-years-old. BMac wanted the Steelers to retain Justin Fields, but the guys questioned how hard the team actually tried. Can the Steelers win a playoff game with Rodgers? Poni thought it was outrageous that BMac has the Bengals as a worse team than the Steelers. Donny Football Debrief – Where do the Steelers fall in the AFC ‘pecking order’ according to a Fox Sports writer?

Former Steeler Bryant McFadden joined the show. Bryant thinks Aaron Rodgers is still a 6 or 7 out of 10 even at 41-years-old. BMac wanted the Steelers to retain Justin Fields, but the guys questioned how hard the team actually tried. Can the Steelers win a playoff game with Rodgers? Poni thought it was outrageous that BMac has the Bengals as a worse team than the Steelers.

What is the ceiling for the Steelers with Aaron Rodgers? What is the worst-case scenario for the Steelers? The guys still pondered if it would be better for their future if they just had one lackluster season.

Steelers correspondent Mark Kaboly from The Pat McAfee Show joined the show. The guys broke down the acquisition of Aaron Rodgers that finally happened. How much better does he make the Steelers? Poni called out Mark for thinking Russell Wilson was also the answer last season. What will Rodgers do differently? Mark thinks the addition of someone like Keenan Allen makes them a threat to win the AFC North. More w/ Mark – Should the Steelers call the Falcons about Kyle Pitts? It didn’t work for him when Arthur Smith was the Falcons head coach, so would it work if he’s the Steelers offensive coordinator? Mark says the idea of trading for Terry McLaurin is the Brandon Aiyuk saga all over again. More w/ Mark – Is Aaron Rodgers still going to appear on the Pat McAfee Show every week? Poni wanted a review of the ‘Next Up on The Fan’ from last night. What if Rodgers never happened and Mason Rudolph ran the show for the full season? Will Rodgers throw for 30 TDs next season?

Steelers Fan insider of the Pat McAfee Show joins Poni in studio

Aaron Rodgers is a Steeler. He’s here. Now what? Are the Steelers a real contender? What is the ceiling with Rodgers as Steelers QB? Poni, sleep deprived, took a fiery call. More fiery calls on Aaron Rodgers. Bucco Minute – We heard Paul Skenes talk about his future a little bit yesterday.

Bucco Minute – We heard Paul Skenes talk about his future a little bit yesterday.

Aaron Rodgers is a Steeler. He’s here. Now what? Are the Steelers a real contender? What is the ceiling with Rodgers as Steelers QB? Poni, sleep deprived, took a fiery call.

Poni and Bechtold continue to react to the breaking news that Aaron Rodgers is joining the Steelers.

Poni and Austin Bechtold react to the breaking news that Aaron Rodgers is joining the Steelers.

Starkey and Mueller back for another hour as the breaking news comes in that Aaron Rodgers has joined the Steelers. Josh Miller joins the guys, as well!

Starkey and Mueller reunite for the Five-Alarm Marathon! The guys reminisce on their time together and share old station stories. Starkey apparently is dominating people at basketball today.

PM Team FULL Show 6-4-25

93.7 The Fan Sports Director Jeff Hathhorn joined the show. Jeff said Beanie Bishop was the big story of today’s OTA session because of the video he posted on Instagram. Jeff backed up what Bishop did and thinks it’s good for rivalries in college football. Jeff said Bishop took it upon himself to speak, but the team didn’t force him to do so. Jeff doesn’t think this is a reason why Bishop could get cut – that would have to be due to on-field performance. Jeff had more love for Kaleb Johnson, who has been getting praise from multiple in the Pittsburgh media lately. How likely is it the Steelers sign Gabe Davis tomorrow? Minkah Fitzpatrick had some words as to why things went wrong on defense last season.

Ben Roethlisberger is trying to change the narrative on how he felt about Mason Rudolph when he was drafted in 2018. The guys went back in time a little bit to remember how it was when Rudolph first got here. Ben has a good relationship with several other backup QBs from his time, but Mason was not one of them. How is Mason looking in OTAs so far? A few insiders say he has been really showing signs of a starting QB. ALL ACCESS w/ Aditi – Aditi described Gabe Davis as ‘intense’ and a good teammate. Aditi brought up a story from one of her days on the sideline with CBS when Davis got upset on the sideline, but was happy to answer questions after the game. Aditi said she’s more excited about Roman Wilson and Calvin Austin than she is about Davis or another middling veteran receiver. Is the Jonnu Smith stuff mostly a play of the agent so the tight end can get a new deal or could he really end up with the Steelers? Some good media chatter as well. Donny Football Debrief – Derrick Henry is an Adam Sandler fan.